Showdown With Dutch
Dutch isn't one to fight fair, and he immediately jumps into an armored gun turret. Two of his men will attack you at the same time, and you'll have to take them out quickly before Dutch turns you into hamburger with the machine gun.
After the guards are down, a quick cutscene shows a lantern hanging behind Dutch. Seems like the perfect way to encourage him to leave the safety of his turret.
A single well-placed shot will destroy the lantern and start a fire, forcing Dutch from the gun. He runs into a nearby building, and you'll have to follow the only path available to you, the stairs and ladder that aren't on fire.
Once you reach the top of the ladder, Dutch takes a shot at you, then disappears one again. Give chase, using the only non-flaming path available. Head inside the upstairs building and into the cave behind it.
Around the corner is a mine shaft, and Duth takes another shot from atop the platform. Climb up after him. Upstairs, round the bend and find Dutch once again waiting for you atop a platform. Keep chasing him.
One more turn in the cave and you'll see the exit. Outside, Dutch peers over the cliff edge. He tosses his gun over the edge, and speaks about the futility of fighting.
He gives up, and John climbs down to pay his respects. Ross appears, and shoots Dutch's body with his gun.
John's family has returned home, and his time working for the feds is over.
For more mission walkthroughs, guides, hints, tips, and more, check out our Ultimate Guide to Red Dead Redemption.