A Cry for Help
Back in town, Ramon, a local resident, rushes up to Ricketts, pleading for his help. Mount your horse, and follow Landon out into the countryside.
Some bandits have taken the driver of the supply wagon hostage, and you'll have to use your newly-upgraded Dead Eye ability to take him out without harming the hostage. Keep your distance, and target the head of the hostage taker (and any other nearby bandits, if you're feeling tricky), then fire away to save the hostage. He'll hop back atop the wagon and head for town, and Landon will advise you to stay close and watch out for more bad guys.
Around a bend in the road, some bandits have set up a road block using a chuck wagon. You can either use your Dead Eye to take them both out, or target the lanterns atop the wagon to set them afire.
Either way, once they're gone the wagon returns safely to Chuparosa, and you've finished "The Gunslinger's Tragedy." Your Dead Eye ability is now level 3, and you've also picked up a new Schofield Revolver for your troubles.
For more mission walkthroughs, cheat codes, weapons guides, and more, check out our Ultimate Guide to Red Dead Redemption.